I did not read the link, but two of my biggest concerns do not appear in the summary you provided :
(Edit: typo)
In my experience, OnlyOffice has the best compatibility with M$ Office. You should try it if you haven’t
2 years ago was already amazing for someone who tried to play CS 1.6 and trackmania using wine 18 years ago
What I did is use a wildcard subdomain and certificate. This way, only pierre-couy.fr
and *.pierre-couy.fr
ever show up in the transparency logs. Since I’m using pi-hole with carefully chosen upstream DNS servers, passive DNS replication services do not seem to pick up my subdomains (but even subdomains I share with some relatives who probably use their ISP’s default DNS do not show up)
This obviously only works if all your subdomains go to the same IP. I’ve achieved something similar to cloudflare tunnels using a combination of nginx and wireguard on a cheap VPS (I want to write a tutorial about this when I find some time). One side benefit of this setup is that I usually don’t need to fiddle with my DNS zone to set up a new subdomains : all I need to do is add a new nginx config file with a server
section.
Some scanners will still try to brute-force subdomains. I simply block any IP that hits my VPS with a Host
header containing a subdomain I did not configure
Thanks for the details ! Still curious to know how a new instance, with an old domain and fresh keys, would be handled by other instances.
I’m pretty sure they are actually hosting it. The tech is quite different (cofractal uses urls ending with {z}/{x}/{y}
, while their tile sever uses this stuff that works quite differently)
There is even a “Ignore cache” box in the devtools network tab
Yeah, this probably has to do with the cache. You can try opening dev tools (F12 in most browsers), go to the network tab, and browse to pathfinder.social. You should see all requests going out, including “fake requests” to content that you already have locally cached
They told me about hosting their own tile server earlier today. I’m really impressed by how fast they moved !
A pull request for a privacy page during the onboarding is in the works, and I’ve been working with them to update the settings page and documentation (with the goal of providing an easy way to switch map providers). They are also working on a privacy policy, and want to ship all of this in a few weeks as part of a single release.
Once again, I’m really impressed with how well they’re handling this
That’s really really weird, I cannot resolve the domain to an IP, even after trying a bunch of different DNS servers. If you’re on linux, can you run nslookup pathfinder.social
and paste the output here ?
The fact that it has not been bought as soon as the domain expired makes me believe this instance went down before the trend started
These services usually use either or both of passive DNS replication (running public recursive DNS resolvers and logging lookup that returns a record) and certificate transparency logs (where certificate authorities publish the domain names for which they issue certificates). A lot of my subdomains are missing from these services
It does not seem to be the case. Was it the full domain for this instance ?
Is named
actually running as the bind
user inside the container ? Maybe a USER bind
line below the RUN
lines will help.
I’ll probably look into newer fancier options such as Caddy one day, but as far as I remember Nginx has never failed me : it’s stable, battle tested, and extremely mature. I can’t remember a single time when I’ve been affected by a breaking change (I could not even find one by searching changelogs) and the feature set makes it very versatile. Newer alternatives seem really interesting, but it seems to me they have quite frequent breaking changes and are not as feature rich.
That being said, I’d love to see side-by-side comparison of Nginx and Caddy configs (if anyone wants to translate to Caddy the Nginx caching proxy for OSM I shared earlier this week, that would make a good and useful example), as well as examples of features missing from Nginx. This may give me enough motivation to actually try Caddy :)
(edit : ad->and)
I don’t use nginx-proxy-manager, but if you want to share what you tried, I will try to help you figure what’s not working
It’s the clients (web/android app, probably iOS too) that are making these requests.
To the best of my knowledge, the Immich server inside the container is not making requests to the outside. It is merely sending a style.json
to the client displaying a map, which then fetches tiles from the Cofractal URL inside this JSON.
Or you can quite easily configure nginx as your personal caching proxy with an arbitrarily long TTL/retention duration (you can check out my follow-up post for instructions on doing that)
I used to wonder what kind of nerd notices this kind of thing, now I’m one of them
Edit : If you want to join us :
I can recommend some stuff I’ve been using myself :
I design, deploy and maintain such infrastructures for my own customers, so feel free to DM me with more details about your business if you need help with this