It’s pre installed on so many student devices. I don’t understand the people saying we need a simple linux alternative. It doesn’t matter if we don’t have vendors pre installing linux. Simple as.

Second best selling consumer Linux platform on the planet, second only to Android.

Is ChromeOS even that successful?

I think this probably makes sense from within your “bubble”, that of being the sort of technical user that’s on a Linux forum on the internet. Chromebooks are incredibly popular in education, and ChromeOS has held a marketshare of 5-8% over the last few years, only dipping to 2.5% in the last six months.

Linux already will run on a literal brick, we just need an OS that is web-first and locked down for high school kids in a way where educational institutions will want to buy it in bulk. As for device, we really need something built to be a modern netbook. The Framework 12 could have been that, but it starts at $1244 in fully base spec with an i3-1315U, no Windows license and DIY. What we need is a Framework 10 without expansion cards, without a digitiser/touch, running the barebones Intel N100 4c/4t, 8GB RAM, 256GB SSD. Make it as repairable but single SKU and pre-built. Partner with someone like Universal Blue for the OS, who they already have as an official partner for other devices with Bazzite. It also needs to be sub-$600 to compete.

By the way, ChromeOS being folded into Android isn’t a negative reflection on it. Google are trying to mimic Samsung DeX with their Pixel devices and it just isn’t a smart business decision to develop two parallel desktop experiences when ChromeOS already runs on the Android kernel anyway. Android also has more brand recognition, and overall it will probably encourage developers to make proper desktop kb+m versions of their apps (which can exist in the same apk). A way for Linux to compete there would be strong system integration of Waydroid but that’s probably mostly a “bonus feature” if they manage to succeed with everything else.

I think at least part of the problem has been the built in expiry date, and the fact that so many off brand Chromebooks are absolute shit. They have tiny screens and low specs, and struggle with multiple web pages open.

I fancied one myself to take out and about, as I do most of my work on my PC, but they all seemed to have under 13 inch screens, and a five year shelf life. I like to research my family tree, so have a few tabs open, but the lack of memory would kill them and make it painful to do.

Google is using the Microsoft Handbook by providing cheap laptops to students so that’s all they get familiar with.